The emissions myth returns

An article in an English-language section of the web site of German magazine Der Spiegel briefly discusses the New Mexico spaceport plans announced last week. But—and you knew there had to be a “but” here—the article weighs that against the “enormous” carbon footprint the suborbital spaceflight from there will generate. The key (and final) sentence from the article, after discussing the environmentally-friendly aspects of the spaceport: “But all the fuss about conservation comes across as a bit empty considering the enormous fuel consumption and carbon footprint of each rocket that will launch from the private spaceport, taking space tourists into orbit for $200,000 a pop.”

This is not the first time that the perceived deleterious effects on the environment by suborbital spaceflights have been brought up; an editorial from a New Hampshire newspaper made similar statements in July. Der Spiegel makes no attempt to quantify how big an “enormous” carbon footprint is (perhaps because it’s not so enormous after all), and that’s just plain sloppy journalism.

4 comments to The emissions myth returns

  • Not to mention the fact that they apparently don’t know the difference between orbit and suborbit.

  • Chance

    While I have never bought into the vast liberal media conspiracy theory, I am constantly disapointed by what passes for journalism. Basic facts incorrect, obvious opinion inserted into supposedly objective analysis, numerous logical fallacies, ect. And this is in some of our better respected papers! If this is what our colleges produce, I’m glad I didn’t go.

  • Peter Shearer

    Oh yes, a 90 second rocket burn twice a day is going to destroy the world. That’s not MUCH people! Oh dear, these poor journalists trying to charge up some interest in THEIR article by throwing in odviously overstated crys about the environment simply because they know it’s on people’s minds.

    I’m pro-environment and pro-spaceflight!

  • Some guy

    I thought Niven & Pournelle’s “Fallen Angels” was a bit extreme when I first read it, but here it comes in real life.

Leave a Reply




You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>